8 Charming Small Towns in New Jersey

If you’re thinking about moving to New Jersey, bustling cities like Newark or Jersey City might come to mind. However, this state has much more to offer. From quaint downtowns to festivals that bring the community together, New Jersey’s small towns are perfect for anyone looking to experience what life is like in its quieter corners. In this Redfin article, we’ll discuss 8 charming small towns in New Jersey, each with their own unique character and plenty of reasons to call home.

1. Villas, NJ

Median Sale Price: $425,000
Homes for Sale in Villas | Apartments for Rent in Villas

Villas is a quiet bayside town known for its laid-back atmosphere and beautiful sunsets over the Delaware Bay. The town’s beaches are less crowded than those on the Atlantic side, making it a peaceful spot for swimming, kayaking, and enjoying the water. Locals love to take evening walks along the Villas Fishing Pier, a favorite spot for casting a line or watching the sun dip below the horizon. Feeling hungry? Dining options here include The Red Brick Ale House, a cozy pub known for its craft beers and seafood dishes.

2. Leonia, NJ

Median Sale Price: $660,500
Homes for Sale in Leonia | Apartments for Rent in Leonia

Leonia is located just a few miles from New York City. The town is home to the Leonia Chamber Musicians, who perform classical concerts throughout the year, adding to the town’s artistic flair. Leonia’s close proximity to the city makes it a popular choice for commuters who want suburban living with easy access to Manhattan. The Overpeck County Park, just on the outskirts of town, has a variety of outdoor activities including kayaking, fishing, and walking trails.

3. Bogota, NJ

Median Sale Price: $560,000
Homes for Sale in Bogota | Apartments for Rent in Bogota

Bogota is a small town in Bergen County that has a close-knit community feel. The town’s main attraction is the Hackensack River, which provides scenic spots for fishing, kayaking, or simply relaxing by the water. Bogota is also known for its annual Bogota Day celebration, a summer event featuring food, games, and live entertainment. For dining, locals love to visit Andy’s Corner Bar, a neighborhood staple known for its extensive selection of craft beers and friendly service.

4. Glen Ridge, NJ

Median Sale Price: $1,100,000
Homes for Sale in Glen Ridge | Apartments for Rent in Glen Ridge

Glen Ridge is a picturesque town with tree-lined streets and charming gas lamps, which add to the town’s historic feel. The town is just a short drive from Montclair, making it a desirable spot for commuters. Glen Ridge is famous for its well-preserved architecture, including beautiful Victorian homes and its stately Glen Ridge Country Club. The town’s Freeman Gardens, a peaceful public park filled with roses and walking paths, is a local gem for relaxation and outdoor enjoyment.

5. Spotswood, NJ

Median Sale Price: $530,000
Homes for Sale in Spotswood | Apartments for Rent in Spotswood

Spotswood’s crown jewel is DeVoe Lake, where locals spend their weekends fishing, kayaking, or taking peaceful strolls along the waterfront. Spotswood’s history dates back to the colonial era, and visitors can explore that heritage through landmarks like the Spotswood Reformed Church, which was established in 1816. For dining, locals rave about the pizza at Nonna’s Citi Cucina, a cozy spot known for its authentic Italian fare.

6. Mystic Island, NJ

Median Sale Price: $385,000
Homes for Sale in Mystic Island | Apartments for Rent in Mystic Island

Mystic Island is a waterfront community with serene lagoons and easy access to the Great Bay. Boating and fishing are a way of life here, with many homes situated directly on the water. This allows many residents to dock their boats right at their doorstep. Mystic Island’s proximity to Long Beach Island and the Jersey Shore means you’re never far from the beach, making it a perfect spot for weekend getaways. The Mystic Island Casino Pub & Grill is a local favorite, offering casual dining and live entertainment throughout the week.

7. Mays Landing, NJ

Median Sale Price: $361,500
Homes for Sale in Mays Landing | Apartments for Rent in Mays Landing

Mays Landing is a historic town located along the Great Egg Harbor River. The town is home to the famous Hamilton Mall, but it’s also known for its scenic parks and outdoor recreation. Locals love taking advantage of the waterways at Lake Lenape Park, where boating, fishing, and picnicking are popular weekend activities. History buffs will enjoy a visit to the Gaskill Park Historical District, featuring preserved 19th-century buildings.

8. Spring Lake, NJ

Median Sale Price: $2,775,000
Homes for Sale in Spring Lake | Apartments for Rent in Spring Lake

Spring Lake, known as the “Jewel of the Jersey Shore,” is an elegant seaside town with a timeless appeal. Its pristine beaches and boardwalk, which stretches for two miles along the Atlantic Ocean, provide a peaceful setting for beachgoers who prefer a more relaxed experience. The town’s picturesque lake, surrounded by Victorian homes and tree-lined streets, is a popular spot for morning jogs or peaceful afternoon walks. Spring Lake is also known for its boutique shopping and fine dining, with restaurants like Whispers serving up gourmet meals in an intimate, historic setting.

Methodology: The median home sale price is from the Redfin Data Center.